Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

Section 2

Foundations of Student Success

The core frameworks campuses use to explain persistence and completion, with practical implications and critiques. The full set of student development theories sits alongside this section.

In this section

2.1Overview of student success theoriesNo single theory explains why students stay, leave, or thrive. The frameworks below are complementary lenses, and each points to a different lever institutions can pull.Key takeaway. Retention is what the institution counts; persistence is what the student experiences. Choose the metric that matches the question.2.2Tinto’s interactionalist model of student departureStudents persist when they become integrated into the academic and social systems of the institution. Departure is a longitudinal process, not a single decision.Key takeaway. Institutions make integration possible. Students do not achieve it alone.2.3Astin’s theory of student involvement (I-E-O)Learning and development are directly proportional to the quality and quantity of physical and psychological energy students invest in educationally purposeful activities.Key takeaway. The I-E-O model is a warning for analytics: without accounting for inputs, environments get credit or blame they did not earn.2.4Sense of belongingStrayhorn defines belonging as students’ perceived social support on campus: a feeling of connectedness, of mattering, of being cared about, accepted, respected, and valued.Key takeaway. Belonging is felt, not counted. Activity data can suggest disconnection but cannot measure belonging directly.2.5Related conceptsShorter treatments of frameworks that extend or challenge the core models.Key takeaway. Engagement and validation both put responsibility on the institution for what it does, alongside what students bring.