Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

2.4 · Foundations of Student Success

Sense of belonging

Strayhorn defines belonging as students’ perceived social support on campus: a feeling of connectedness, of mattering, of being cared about, accepted, respected, and valued.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.
Visual model · Seven core elements of sense of belonging (Strayhorn)

Select an element for details.

1Basic human need Belonging is a universal human need.

Strayhorn builds on Maslow and on Baumeister and Leary’s “need to belong” to argue that belonging is a basic human need. Every student has it, including those who seem confident or well prepared.

When the need goes unmet, students spend energy managing doubt and isolation that would otherwise go to learning. That is why belonging problems often show up first as missed classes or disengagement, not as a request for help.

What the research says

Baumeister and Leary’s review found the need to belong is universal and that its absence is linked to stress, poorer health, and weaker functioning. In college samples, belonging predicts intent to persist even after controlling for grades (Hausmann et al., 2007).

Signs to watch for

  • A student who stops attending without telling anyone
  • Few or no peer connections by week four
  • Comments such as “I don’t know anyone here”

In practice

  • Plan belonging into the first contact a student has with the institution, not after problems appear.
  • Treat signs of isolation as seriously as academic warning signs.

Technology touchpoint. Welcome outreach from a named person before term starts

Watch out for

  • Treating belonging as a social extra that comes after academics
  • Assuming students who look fine do not need it

Where does a new student first feel that someone on campus knows them?

2Fundamental motive The need is strong enough to drive behavior.

Because the need is strong, it drives behavior. Students look for belonging and organize their time around where they find it.

That search can support learning, as in study groups and student organizations, or compete with it, as when a student’s main community is a job or friends who are not in school. Institutions do better by offering easy routes to academic communities than by asking students to give up others.

What the research says

Students who join at least one campus organization or learning community in the first year report higher belonging and are more likely to persist, though self-selection makes the size of the effect hard to pin down (Strayhorn, 2019; Kuh, 2008).

Signs to watch for

  • Students eating alone or leaving campus right after class
  • Heavy reliance on one off-campus group for support
  • Low participation in optional academic activities

In practice

  • Offer easy, low-stakes ways to connect with peers who share interests or goals.
  • Pay attention to where students are finding belonging, including off campus and online.

Technology touchpoint. Community features that make shared-interest peers easy to find

Watch out for

  • Designing belonging only for residential, traditional-age students
  • Counting club sign-ups instead of real participation

Which groups on your campus are students already choosing, and how can you support them?

3Context matters It is heightened in certain contexts, at certain times, for certain populations.

Belonging is not a fixed trait. It rises and falls with setting, time, and who else is in the room.

It matters most during transitions, after setbacks, and in settings where a student is one of few people like them. A first-generation student may feel at home in a learning community and out of place in a large lecture on the same day.

What the research says

Walton and Cohen’s brief social-belonging intervention, which reframed early struggles as common and temporary, raised GPA for Black students over three years and cut the achievement gap roughly in half in their sample. A later multi-campus study found similar effects for students from groups underrepresented in college (Murphy et al., 2020).

Signs to watch for

  • A drop in engagement right after the first exams
  • Underrepresented students leaving a major after one gateway course
  • Lower belonging scores in specific courses or programs

In practice

  • Time outreach to transitions: the first weeks, after a failed exam, after a transfer.
  • Look closely at settings, such as gateway STEM courses, where some groups are underrepresented.

Technology touchpoint. Time outreach to transitions: first weeks, setbacks, transfer

Watch out for

  • Sending the same message to every student at the same time
  • Ignoring course-level climate in gateway classes

When in the term do your students most need to hear from someone?

4Mattering Belonging is related to, and a consequence of, mattering.

Mattering is the sense that others notice you, care about you, and would miss you. Schlossberg described it as a need that grows sharper during transitions, when students feel marginal.

Strayhorn treats belonging as partly a result of mattering. Students who believe they matter to faculty, staff, or peers are more likely to feel they belong.

What the research says

Rosenberg and McCullough introduced mattering as a measurable construct; Schlossberg applied it to college transitions. Studies of first-year students link perceived mattering to lower stress and stronger academic engagement.

Signs to watch for

  • No staff member could name the student’s goals
  • Automated messages are the only contact a student receives
  • A student says no one would notice if they left

In practice

  • Make outreach personal: use the student’s name, goals, and a named contact.
  • Follow up when a student goes quiet, and say why you noticed.

Technology touchpoint. Personalized messages that reference the student’s own goals

Watch out for

  • Generic mass messages that make students feel more anonymous
  • Outreach that stops after one attempt

Would a student on your campus be missed if they stopped showing up? Who would notice?

5Intersecting identities Social identities intersect and shape belonging.

Students hold several identities at once, such as race, gender, class, sexuality, disability, and first-generation status. How those identities interact shapes where they feel they belong.

A student may feel connected in a cultural center and isolated in their major, or welcomed by peers and doubted by an instructor. Campus averages hide these differences.

What the research says

National data show belonging gaps by race and first-generation status, with the lowest scores for students holding more than one marginalized identity (Gopalan & Brady, 2020). Hurtado and Carter found that campus racial climate shapes belonging for Latino students.

Signs to watch for

  • Belonging survey gaps between groups
  • Students of color reporting they are often the only one in class
  • Low use of identity-based centers by students who might benefit

In practice

  • Connect students to identity-based communities and to mentors who share their experiences.
  • Disaggregate belonging survey results instead of reporting one campus average.

Technology touchpoint. Connect students to identity-based communities and centers

Watch out for

  • Reporting one campus-wide belonging score
  • Placing the work of inclusion on identity-based offices alone

Which students report the lowest belonging in your data, and in which settings?

6Outcomes Belonging leads to positive outcomes; its absence to negative ones.

Belonging is linked to engagement, persistence, well-being, and achievement. Its absence is linked to stress, withdrawal, and leaving.

Strayhorn presents belonging both as an outcome worth pursuing for its own sake and as a pathway to the outcomes institutions report, such as retention and graduation.

What the research says

A 2024 scoping review found small-to-moderate positive links between belonging and motivation, self-efficacy, and engagement, and weaker but positive links with grades and retention (Fong et al., 2024).

Signs to watch for

  • Belonging is not measured at all
  • Retention reports that never mention student experience

In practice

  • Measure belonging directly, with validated items, before and after interventions.
  • Report belonging alongside retention and grades.

Technology touchpoint. Track belonging items alongside retention in evaluations

Watch out for

  • Treating belonging only as a means to retention
  • Using a single survey item as the whole measure

Do you measure belonging, or only infer it from other outcomes?

7Continual It must be satisfied on an ongoing basis and changes with circumstances.

Belonging is not established once. It has to be renewed as students move through new settings: from the first year into a major, from a community college to a university, from classes into internships.

Each change can reset a student’s sense of fit, even for students who felt at home before.

What the research says

Transfer students often report a drop in belonging after moving to a four-year campus, sometimes called transfer shock. Belonging also tends to dip for students entering competitive majors after the first year.

Signs to watch for

  • Belonging programs that end after the first year
  • Transfer students with no orientation to their new major
  • Drops in engagement after changing majors

In practice

  • Build check-ins into later transitions as well as the first year.
  • Watch for drops in belonging after major changes, such as switching majors or a family event.

Technology touchpoint. Sustain contact beyond the first term; avoid one-off campaigns

Watch out for

  • Front-loading all belonging work into orientation
  • Assuming upper-level students no longer need support

What happens to belonging support after the first year on your campus?

Why it matters for persistence
Belonging is a basic human need that grows more salient in unfamiliar contexts, for students who are marginalized, and at moments of transition. It is especially consequential for underrepresented and first-generation students.
Relationship to Tinto
Social integration describes participation in campus life; belonging describes the student’s subjective sense of fit. A student can be involved yet still feel they do not belong (Hurtado & Carter, 1997).
Belonging is contextual
Students can belong in a lab or a club but not the institution as a whole. Belonging uncertainty can be reduced through brief, well-designed interventions (Walton & Cohen, 2011).

Practical strategies

  • Classrooms: learn names, normalize struggle, use structured collaboration, and signal that all students are expected to succeed.
  • Advising: open with the student’s goals and strengths before deficits; follow up when a student goes quiet.
  • Residence halls: build floor communities around shared interests and identities, with peer mentors trained in outreach.
  • Campus spaces: make cultural centers, commuter lounges, and study spaces visible and resourced.

Theories behind this section