In this section
3.1Six kinds of frameworks“Framework” covers very different things. Knowing which kind you are using tells you what evidence to ask for.Key takeaway. Match the evidence to the claim. Support for a practice does not validate the whole framework it came from.3.2Foundational explanationsThe classic persistence and involvement models still shape most campus thinking. Each explains part of the picture.Key takeaway. These models explain persistence well. On their own they say less about learning, material conditions, equity, and life after college.3.3Mechanism-centered frameworksThese frameworks explain why the same experience can motivate one student and discourage another.Key takeaway. A strong organizing lens. Adopting the framework is not itself an intervention; specific practices still need evaluation.3.4Equity-centered frameworksThese frameworks change the explanation itself, placing responsibility on the institution rather than asking students to fit in.Key takeaway. Equity frameworks are design guides. Measurement validity and explained variance are not proof that an intervention works.3.5Institutional, national, and state frameworksCampuses and associations publish frameworks to organize strategy. They are useful maps, but most have not been evaluated as frameworks.Key takeaway. Institutional frameworks show what a campus values. Ask what evidence supports each practice inside them.3.6Defining success: outcomes frameworksResearchers agree success is broader than grades and graduation. They differ on how to divide it up.Key takeaway. No integrated taxonomy has been widely validated. Use several dimensions, and say which one each measure tracks.3.7What the evidence supportsCausal evidence is strongest for comprehensive programs and specific teaching practices, not for frameworks as a whole.Key takeaway. Fund what has been tested, and evaluate the rest. Single interventions usually move outcomes less than coordinated packages.3.8Putting frameworks togetherGive each framework a clear job instead of choosing one as campus doctrine.Key takeaway. Keep theoretical coherence and demonstrated effectiveness separate. A framework can be well reasoned and still untested.3.9Framework profilesThe same nine questions asked of each major framework, so they can be compared side by side.Key takeaway. A framework can be coherent, empirically supported, and still untested as an intervention. The profiles keep those three apart.3.10How evidence is classified on this siteSix evidence types, from strongest causal support to conceptual argument. Each claim should say which type it rests on.Key takeaway. Name the evidence type every time you cite a result.