Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

3.1 · Student Success Frameworks

Six kinds of frameworks

“Framework” covers very different things. Knowing which kind you are using tells you what evidence to ask for.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.
Explanatory theories
Ask why students persist, depart, engage, or develop. Tinto, Bean and Metzner, and Astin. Evidence: longitudinal studies, qualitative inquiry, theory testing.
Mechanism-centered frameworks
Ask how experiences affect outcomes, through self-efficacy, emotion, belonging, and motivation. Kahu and Nelson’s educational interface; self-determination theory.
Equity-centered frameworks
Ask how recognition, culture, power, and institutional environments shape opportunity. Rendón’s validation theory; Museus’s CECE model; ecological validation.
Organizational reform frameworks
Ask how an institution should redesign its work. Guided Pathways; Kuh’s DEEP conditions; the ACE Learner Success model.
Program models
Specify a service package that can be evaluated. CUNY ASAP; structured coaching.
Outcomes frameworks
Define what should count as success. York, Gibson, and Rankin; Lane and colleagues; institutional frameworks such as USC’s. Defining an outcome is not the same as showing an intervention works.

Four claims that need different evidence

  • Belonging is associated with persistence (correlational studies).
  • A survey measures belonging validly (measurement studies).
  • An intervention increases persistence (experiments).
  • Adopting a belonging-centered institutional framework improves graduation (institution-level evaluation). Evidence for the first three does not establish the fourth.