Ask why students persist, depart, engage, or develop. Tinto, Bean and Metzner, and Astin. Evidence: longitudinal studies, qualitative inquiry, theory testing.
Mechanism-centered frameworks
Ask how experiences affect outcomes, through self-efficacy, emotion, belonging, and motivation. Kahu and Nelson’s educational interface; self-determination theory.
Equity-centered frameworks
Ask how recognition, culture, power, and institutional environments shape opportunity. Rendón’s validation theory; Museus’s CECE model; ecological validation.
Organizational reform frameworks
Ask how an institution should redesign its work. Guided Pathways; Kuh’s DEEP conditions; the ACE Learner Success model.
Program models
Specify a service package that can be evaluated. CUNY ASAP; structured coaching.
Outcomes frameworks
Define what should count as success. York, Gibson, and Rankin; Lane and colleagues; institutional frameworks such as USC’s. Defining an outcome is not the same as showing an intervention works.
Four claims that need different evidence
Belonging is associated with persistence (correlational studies).
A survey measures belonging validly (measurement studies).
An intervention increases persistence (experiments).
Adopting a belonging-centered institutional framework improves graduation (institution-level evaluation). Evidence for the first three does not establish the fourth.