Bean & Metzner: Nontraditional Student Attrition
For older, part-time, and commuter students, the external environment (finances, work hours, family) shapes persistence more than social integration does.
Key ideas
- 01 Turnover model: Bean (1980) modeled attrition on employee turnoverDiscussed in 2.2 Tinto’s interactionalist model of student departure →
- 02 Environmental variables: finances, hours of employment, outside encouragement, family responsibilitiesDiscussed in 3.9 Framework profiles →
- 03 Academic variables: study habits, advising, course availabilityDiscussed in 3.9 Framework profiles →
- 04 Psychological outcomes: utility, satisfaction, goal commitment, stressDiscussed in 3.9 Framework profiles →
- 05 Intent to leave: a strong proximal predictor of departureDiscussed in 3.9 Framework profiles →
At a glance
- Attrition of nontraditional students
- Student and external environment
- Environmental pull, intent to leave
- Commuter, adult, and part-time strategy
Helps explain
- Why integration-focused programs miss commuter and adult students
- Why aid and scheduling changes can outperform engagement programs
- Community college and part-time persistence
In practice
Emergency aid, predictable block scheduling, evening and online services, credit for prior learning, and employer partnerships.
Critiques and limits
- Less attention to identity and campus climate
- Treats the student largely as an economic actor
- Older model; nontraditional is now the majority
Evidence
Correlational path models. Consistent with later findings that social integration has weak empirical support in commuter settings (Braxton, Hirschy, & McClendon, 2004).
Equity note. Low-income, working, and parenting students are most affected by the external factors this model names. Audit cost and time barriers first.
Related theories
References