Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

Student development theories

Connections & Comparisons

Every theory on the same dimensions, plus curated side-by-side comparisons of commonly paired theories.

Tinto vs. Strayhorn · Person-Environment vs. Contemporary

Integration vs. belonging

Where they align

  • Both locate persistence in connection to campus
  • Both treat relationships with peers and faculty as central
  • Both see the first year as a critical window

Where they differ

  • Tinto frames fit as integration into existing campus norms; Strayhorn frames belonging as a felt sense of mattering
  • Strayhorn foregrounds identity and marginalization; early Tinto did not
  • Integration is behavioral and structural; belonging is psychological and contextual

When to use which

  • Use Tinto to design structures that connect students to academic and social life
  • Use Strayhorn to ask whether those structures work for every group
  • Use both when retention gaps differ by identity
Astin vs. Chickering · Person-Environment vs. Psychosocial

Involvement as mechanism vs. vectors as outcomes

Where they align

  • Both see development as reaching beyond grades
  • Both hold that campus environments shape growth
  • Both support co-curricular learning

Where they differ

  • Astin explains how development happens (involvement); Chickering describes what develops (vectors)
  • Astin is measured in time and energy; Chickering in developmental change
  • I-E-O is an assessment model; the vectors are a developmental map

When to use which

  • Use Astin to design and assess engagement opportunities
  • Use Chickering to define the growth those opportunities should produce
  • Use both to connect a program’s activities to its intended outcomes
Baxter Magolda vs. Perry · Both Cognitive-Structural

Self-authorship and cognitive development

Where they align

  • Both describe a shift from relying on authority to constructing knowledge
  • Both grew from longitudinal interviews with college students
  • Both see dissonance as a driver of growth

Where they differ

  • Perry focuses on intellectual and ethical reasoning; Baxter Magolda adds intrapersonal and interpersonal dimensions
  • Perry ends at commitment within relativism; Baxter Magolda follows participants into adulthood
  • Baxter Magolda is often also classed as integrative

When to use which

  • Use Perry to understand how students approach knowledge in a course
  • Use Baxter Magolda for advising, leadership, and life decisions
  • Use both when designing curricula that build independent judgment
Chickering vs. Strayhorn · Psychosocial vs. Contemporary

Identity development and belonging

Where they align

  • Both treat identity and relationships as central to success
  • Both see environments as able to support or hinder growth
  • Both inform mentoring and residential work

Where they differ

  • Chickering describes individual developmental tasks; Strayhorn describes a need met in context
  • Strayhorn centers marginalized students; Chickering’s research base did not
  • Belonging can rise or fall quickly; vectors describe long-term growth

When to use which

  • Use Chickering to frame long-term developmental goals
  • Use Strayhorn to assess whether students feel they matter right now
  • Use both when identity-based programs aim at growth and retention
Kohlberg vs. Gilligan · Both Cognitive-Structural

Justice and care

Where they align

  • Both describe moral reasoning developing through levels
  • Both move from self-focus toward broader principles or care
  • Both are grounded in interviews about moral dilemmas

Where they differ

  • Kohlberg centers justice, rights, and universal principles; Gilligan centers care and responsibility
  • Kohlberg’s original sample was all male; Gilligan studied women facing real decisions
  • Kohlberg relied on hypothetical dilemmas; Gilligan on lived ones

When to use which

  • Use Kohlberg for conversations about rules, fairness, and accountability
  • Use Gilligan when relationships and responsibilities drive the decision
  • Use both to widen what counts as mature moral reasoning
Tinto vs. Yosso · Person-Environment vs. Contemporary

Integration vs. community cultural wealth

Where they align

  • Both care about why students persist
  • Both see family and community as important to outcomes
  • Both inform first-year and transition programs

Where they differ

  • Early Tinto framed home communities as something to separate from; Yosso frames them as sources of capital
  • Tinto asks how students fit the institution; Yosso asks whether the institution recognizes what students bring
  • Tinto comes from the sociology of departure; Yosso from critical race theory

When to use which

  • Use Tinto to design connection structures
  • Use Yosso to make those structures asset-based
  • Use both to audit programs for deficit assumptions
Strayhorn vs. Walton & Cohen · Both Contemporary / Belonging

Belonging as need vs. belonging as interpretation

Where they align

  • Both treat belonging as central to persistence
  • Both see belonging as heightened for marginalized students
  • Both say belonging is contextual and changeable

Where they differ

  • Strayhorn frames belonging as a basic need met through support and mattering; Walton focuses on doubt and how students interpret adversity
  • Strayhorn’s evidence is mostly correlational and qualitative; Walton’s is experimental
  • Walton offers a brief, scalable intervention; Strayhorn points to sustained relationships and environments

When to use which

  • Use Strayhorn to design the relationships and spaces that create belonging
  • Use Walton to shape first-year messaging and advising conversations
  • Use both: the message works only where the environment makes it true
Kim vs. Nadal vs. Accapadi · Social Identity

Three views of Asian American identity

Where they align

  • All three treat racial and ethnic identity as real developmental work for Asian American students
  • All see sociopolitical awareness as a turning point
  • All push back on the model minority stereotype

Where they differ

  • Kim describes a panethnic stage sequence
  • Nadal adds Filipino American history and the experience of being marginalized within Asian American spaces
  • Accapadi drops stages for many points of consciousness that shift in salience

When to use which

  • Use Kim to plan APIDA programs and staff training
  • Use Nadal when serving Filipino American students and when deciding whether to disaggregate data
  • Use Accapadi to design for the full range of Asian American students, including South and Southeast Asian, immigrant, and refugee students