Accapadi: Asian American Identity Consciousness
Asian American identity is shaped by many points of consciousness at once, such as ethnicity, immigration history, family, religion, class, and phenotype, rather than by a single sequence of stages.
Key ideas
- 01 Polycultural model: identity draws on several cultures and communities at the same timeDiscussed in 2.2 Tinto’s interactionalist model of student departure →
- 02 Points of consciousness: ethnicity, family, immigration and generational history, religion, class, gender and sexuality, phenotype, and geography
- 03 Critical incidents: events that make one point of identity suddenly salient
- 04 Non-linear: students move among points of consciousness rather than up a ladder
At a glance
- Asian American identity
- The individual in context
- Shifting salience of multiple identities
- Inclusive APIDA programs and advising
Helps explain
- Why two Asian American students can have very different college experiences
- How immigration and generational status shape identity and family expectations
- Why South Asian and Southeast Asian students may not see themselves in “Asian American” programs
In practice
Design APIDA programming for several communities, ask students which identities feel most salient, and pay attention to immigrant and refugee family histories.
Critiques and limits
- Harder to operationalize than stage models
- Less tested in empirical research
- Published in a practitioner volume rather than a journal
Equity note. Pushes institutions to see the range of Asian American experiences instead of one monolithic group.
Related theories
References