Belonging
Students’ felt sense of mattering and connection, a strong predictor of persistence and wellbeing, especially for students from marginalized groups.
- Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging
- The core model: mattering, connectedness, and fit in context.
- Rendón: Validation Theory
- Validation by faculty and staff builds belonging.
- Tinto: Student Departure / Integration
- Social integration is the earlier, structural version of the idea.
- Museus: Culturally Engaging Campus Environments (CECE)
- Culturally engaging environments predict belonging.
- Walton & Cohen: Belonging Uncertainty
- Brief interventions work where belonging affordances exist.
- Kim: Asian American Identity Development
- Racial identity security shapes belonging for Asian American students.
- Nadal: Pilipino American Identity Development
- Filipino American students may feel unseen in panethnic spaces.
- Accapadi: Asian American Identity Consciousness
- Different points of identity shape where students feel at home.
- Phinney: Ethnic Identity Development
- Ethnic identity is linked to well-being and belonging.
- Torres: Latino/a Ethnic Identity
- Family and environment shape identity in the first two years.
- Renn: Multiracial Identity Patterns
- Campus spaces can include or exclude multiracial students.
- D’Augelli: Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Identity Development
- LGB community and family response shape belonging.
- Bilodeau: Transgender Identity Development
- Institutional systems can signal who belongs.
- Sue: Racial Microaggressions
- Everyday slights erode belonging.
- Du Bois: Double Consciousness
- Navigating a campus gaze.
- Paris & Alim: Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy
- Keeping one’s culture and language.
Questions For Your Campus
- Who on campus would notice if this student disappeared?
- Which spaces reflect students’ identities, and which do not?
Scenario Ids
- mentoring
- residence-hall
- belonging-module
Persistence
Why students stay, stop out, or leave, and which conditions the institution can change.
- Tinto: Student Departure / Integration
- Departure as a process of insufficient integration.
- Kuh: Student Engagement / High-Impact Practices
- High-impact practices raise persistence when done well.
- Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging
- Belonging explains gaps that integration alone misses.
- Harper: Anti-Deficit Achievement Framework
- Ask how persisters succeeded.
- Bean & Metzner: Nontraditional Student Attrition
- External factors drive attrition for nontraditional students.
- Ladson-Billings: Culturally Relevant Pedagogy
- Gateway teaching that works for students of color.
- LatCrit: LatCrit and Transformational Resistance
- Transformational resistance can sustain persistence.
- Kirkness & Barnhardt: The Four Rs of Indigenous Higher Education
- Relevance and reciprocity keep Native students enrolled.
Questions For Your Campus
- Where in the first year does disconnection start?
- Which policies make leaving easier than staying?
Scenario Ids
- first-year-seminar
- probation
First-generation students
Students navigating college without family experience of its unwritten rules, often while working or supporting family.
- Rendón: Validation Theory
- Developed with first-generation and low-income students.
- Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging
- Belonging differs measurably by first-generation status.
- Baxter Magolda: Self-Authorship
- Navigating two worlds can prompt self-authorship early.
- Yosso: Community Cultural Wealth
- Names the assets first-gen students bring.
- Stephens: Cultural Mismatch
- Cultural mismatch with independent norms.
- Tinto: Student Departure / Integration
- Its early “separation” stage was critiqued for asking first-gen students to break from home communities; later work stresses connection to both worlds.
- Bean & Metzner: Nontraditional Student Attrition
- Built for commuting, working, and older students, many of them first-generation; external factors like work and family outweigh campus social life.
- Schlossberg: Transition Theory
- Mattering and marginality describe how first-gen students can feel unseen during the move into college.
- Schlossberg (Mattering): Mattering and Marginality
- Feeling noticed and missed by someone on campus is a strong buffer for students without family experience of college.
- Walton & Cohen: Belonging Uncertainty
- Brief social-belonging interventions show some of their largest gains for first-generation and other underrepresented students.
- Museus: Culturally Engaging Campus Environments (CECE)
- Culturally engaging environments let first-gen students stay connected to family and community while in college.
- Harper: Anti-Deficit Achievement Framework
- Anti-deficit questions ask how first-gen students succeed, alongside why some leave.
- Bronfenbrenner: Ecological Systems (applied by Renn)
- Places family, work, and community alongside campus in a first-gen student’s ecosystem.
- Nadal: Pilipino American Identity Development
- Many Filipino American students are first-generation and children of immigrants.
- Accapadi: Asian American Identity Consciousness
- Immigration and generational history are central points of consciousness.
- Torres: Latino/a Ethnic Identity
- Generational status shapes Latino/a students’ identity and choices.
- Horse: American Indian Identity
- Many Native students are first in their families to attend college.
- Moll & González: Funds of Knowledge
- Family and work knowledge as assets.
- Anzaldúa: Borderlands and Mestiza Consciousness
- Living between home and campus.
Questions For Your Campus
- Which expectations on campus are never written down?
- How do work and family obligations limit involvement?
Scenario Ids
- first-gen
- transfer
Equity
Whether supports, experiences, and outcomes are distributed fairly across student groups, and who is asked to adapt.
- Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging
- Centers students from marginalized groups.
- Kuh: Student Engagement / High-Impact Practices
- Access to high-impact practices is unequal.
- Tinto: Student Departure / Integration
- Read with its critique: integration can mean assimilation.
- Hurtado: Campus Racial Climate
- Climate is an institutional responsibility.
- Yosso: Community Cultural Wealth
- Replaces deficit framing with cultural wealth.
- Kim: Asian American Identity Development
- Challenges the model minority myth.
- Nadal: Pilipino American Identity Development
- Makes the case for disaggregating APIDA data.
- Accapadi: Asian American Identity Consciousness
- Shows the range of experiences within “Asian American.”
- Ferdman & Gallegos: Latino Racial Identity Orientations
- Race categories may not match how Latino students see themselves.
- Horse: American Indian Identity
- Tribal sovereignty and community obligations shape persistence.
- Helms: White Racial Identity
- Puts racial learning on White students and staff too.
- Bilodeau: Transgender Identity Development
- Barriers sit in binary systems institutions control.
- Critical Race Theory: Critical Race Theory in Education
- Names how neutral policies produce racial gaps.
- Crenshaw: Intersectionality
- Disaggregate at intersections.
- Brayboy: Tribal Critical Race Theory
- Sovereignty and self-determination in policy.
- AsianCrit: Asian Critical Race Theory
- Counters the model minority assumption.
- Kirkness & Barnhardt: The Four Rs of Indigenous Higher Education
- Puts the burden of change on institutions.
Questions For Your Campus
- Do outcomes differ by group among students with similar preparation?
- Who is asked to change: the student or the institution?
Scenario Ids
- mentoring
- first-gen
Community / village models
Shared responsibility for student success across faculty, staff, peers, and families, rather than a single office.
- Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging
- Villages create many points of mattering.
- Rendón: Validation Theory
- Every agent in the village can validate.
- Astin: Involvement / I-E-O Model
- Every office is part of the environment in I-E-O.
- Schlossberg (Mattering): Mattering and Marginality
- Villages make students feel noticed and needed.
Questions For Your Campus
- Who is in each student’s village?
- How do offices share what they learn about a student?
Scenario Ids
- residence-hall
- transfer
Thriving and well-being
Success defined beyond GPA and completion: academic engagement, relationships, and well-being across dimensions such as emotional, financial, social, physical, intellectual, spiritual, and occupational.
- Schreiner: Thriving
- Thriving as academic, interpersonal, and intrapersonal flourishing.
- Chickering: Seven Vectors
- Development across seven vectors of the whole person.
- Dweck & Canning: Student and Faculty Mindsets
- How students interpret struggle affects well-being.
- Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging
- Belonging is linked to fewer depressive and anxiety symptoms.
- D’Augelli: Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Identity Development
- Supportive context is linked to well-being.
- Bilodeau: Transgender Identity Development
- Inclusive policies support transgender students’ well-being.
- Smith: Racial Battle Fatigue
- Racial stress drains well-being.
- bell hooks: Engaged Pedagogy
- Teaching that attends to the whole person.
Questions For Your Campus
- Which students are persisting but not thriving?
- Do your success metrics include well-being?
Scenario Ids
- first-gen
- residence-hall