Harper: Anti-Deficit Achievement Framework
Instead of asking why students from underserved groups fail, ask how they succeed: and design from what achievers reveal.
Key ideas
- 01 Anti-deficit questions: reframe “why do they leave?” as “how did they persist?”Discussed in 9.5 Questions for institutional conversations →
- 02 Pre-college socialization: family, school, and community influences on readiness
- 03 College achievement: classroom experiences, engagement, and out-of-class involvementDiscussed in 2.4 Sense of belonging →
- 04 Post-college success: graduate school and career readinessDiscussed in 2.4 Sense of belonging →
- 05 Achievers as experts: students who succeed are sources of institutional knowledge
At a glance
- How underserved students succeed
- Student achievers
- Anti-deficit inquiry
- Assessment and program design
Helps explain
- Designing research and assessment questions
- Programs for Black men and other underserved students
- Changing how staff talk about students
In practice
Assessment redesign, peer mentoring led by achievers, and men of color initiatives.
Critiques and limits
- Developed with Black men; transfer to other groups needs care
- Achievers may differ systematically from peers
- Can understate structural barriers
Equity note. An equity reframe at its core: it treats underserved students as experts on their own success.
Related theories
References