Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

6.2 · Theory–Technology Bridge

Mapping examples

Four common goals, each traced from theory to tool to evidence to risk.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.

Tinto: Student Departure / Integration

Supporting academic and social integration

Mechanism
Early, connected experiences in the classroom and community strengthen commitment.
Technology
Early-alert flags on missed classes and early grades routed to a named advisor; learning-community enrollment analytics.
Evidence to track
Time from flag to human contact; second-term re-enrollment for contacted vs. comparable students.
Risk
Treating integration as the student’s job; flags without capacity to respond.

Astin: Involvement / I-E-O Model

Measuring and increasing involvement

Mechanism
Development is proportional to the quality and quantity of energy invested.
Technology
Co-curricular participation data and LMS engagement linked to program design reviews.
Evidence to track
Changes in participation across groups after redesign; NSSE engagement indicators.
Risk
Counting attendance as involvement; ignoring students with little discretionary time.

Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging

Fostering sense of belonging

Mechanism
Perceived support, connection, and mattering sustain persistence.
Technology
Personalized outreach drafted with AI and sent by a known person; chatbot handoffs to mentors and offices.
Evidence to track
Belonging survey items; response and handoff rates; student feedback on tone.
Risk
Automated messages that feel generic; replacing people with bots.

Harper: Anti-Deficit Achievement Framework

Surfacing and closing equity gaps

Mechanism
Gaps reflect institutional practices that can be changed (equity-minded, anti-deficit).
Technology
Disaggregated dashboards on course outcomes and policies; audits of model error by group.
Evidence to track
Narrowing gaps in gateway courses; policy changes traced to data.
Risk
Reducing students to risk scores; locating the deficit in students rather than structures.

Theories behind this section