The eight dimensions are this site’s synthesis, not a validated model. They draw on four institutional frameworks (USC, CSU, ACE, SREB), three research taxonomies (Kuh et al., 2006; York et al., 2015; Vugteveen et al.’s 2025 scoping review of 274 studies), and student-defined success (Sundararaman et al., 2025). The table shows which source contributes to each dimension, and each pop-up lists its evidence and how to measure it.
The eight do different jobs. Five are outcomes students achieve or experience. Belonging and agency are also mechanisms that help explain other outcomes. Health is both an outcome and a condition, and material security works mainly as a condition. Each pop-up names its role. The links between dimensions are conceptual; the site does not claim they are established causal effects.
Two things sit around all eight rather than among them. Institutional capacity (leadership, staffing, coordination, data, and culture) is a condition that shapes every dimension. Equity is a standard applied to each one: who has access, who benefits, and whose goals count.
Students’ own goals matter too. In one review of 52 studies, only one asked students how they define success (Weatherton & Schussler, 2021).
Select an element for details.
1Learning What students understand, can evaluate, create, and apply.
Role: Outcome. Something students achieve or experience, valued for its own sake.
Learning is not the same as grades or completion. A student can earn credits without deep learning, and GPA is only a proxy. York, Gibson, and Rankin found most research measures success through grades even though definitions are much broader.
Measure it with: Direct learning assessments, course mastery, critical thinking and communication rubrics.
Where this dimension comes from
- York et al. (2015): attainment of learning objectives; acquisition of skills
- CSU: curricula and teaching
- ACE: curriculum and co-curriculum
- USC: academic success (partial)
What the research says
Active learning in undergraduate STEM raised exam performance by about 0.47 standard deviations; failure rates averaged 21.8% versus 33.8% under lecture (Freeman et al., 2014). It also narrowed gaps for underrepresented students by 33% on exams and 45% in pass rates (Theobald et al., 2020). Strong evidence, STEM-specific.
In practice
- Treat teaching design as a student success lever, not only advising and services.
- Pair grades with direct assessments of learning.
Technology touchpoint. Learning analytics show activity, not learning. LMS clicks are not demonstrated understanding.
Related on this site
Sources
2Progress and completion Momentum toward students’ goals: credits, transitions, transfer, and credentials.
Role: Outcome. Something students achieve or experience, valued for its own sake.
Progress covers course success, credit momentum, transfer, and completion, measured against what the student is trying to do. Clear pathways through entry, transfer, and major choice belong here. Track transfer and continued education separately from returning to the same campus.
Measure it with: Credits earned, milestones, transfer, completion at 100% and 150% time, disaggregated.
Where this dimension comes from
- USC: academic success
- CSU: academic support and guidance; student transitions
- ACE: completion; mobility
- SREB: access, persistence, retention, attainment
- York et al. (2015): persistence
What the research says
CUNY ASAP raised three-year graduation from about 22% to 40% in a randomized trial; the Ohio replication found 35% versus 19%. After fourteen years, 57.7% of students offered ASAP had a degree versus 50.0% of controls. The effect belongs to the full package, which requires full-time enrollment.
Signs to watch for
- Stalled credit accumulation
- Excess credits at graduation
- Transfer students repeating courses
In practice
- Publish program maps and audit lost transfer credit.
- Front-load support in the first year and at each transition.
Technology touchpoint. Degree planning and early-alert tools support this dimension when a person acts on the signal.
Related on this site
3Belonging and validation Connection, respect, and being affirmed as capable.
Role: Outcome and mechanism. Valued in its own right and also a pathway through which other outcomes are thought to improve.
Belonging is both an outcome students value and a mechanism that supports persistence. Validation adds the institution’s part: faculty, staff, family, and community actively affirming that students are capable and that their knowledge counts.
Measure it with: Validated belonging and mattering scales, disaggregated; reports of validating relationships.
Where this dimension comes from
- CSU: belonging and well-being; ecological validation
- USC: experiential engagement (partial)
What the research says
A brief belonging intervention with 26,911 students at 22 institutions improved first-year full-time completion by about two points for groups with historically lower persistence, but only where real opportunities to belong existed (Walton et al., 2023). Meta-analyses find belonging correlates about .15–.20 with performance and retention and .30–.40 with motivation and well-being.
In practice
- Pair belonging messages with real opportunities to connect.
- Measure campus connection, classroom recognition, and trusted relationships separately.
Technology touchpoint. Automated nudges can support belonging only if they lead to human contact.
Related on this site
4Health and well-being Mental and physical health, balance, and sustainable participation.
Role: Outcome and condition. Part of success itself and also a condition that shapes learning and progress.
Students name health, balance, and manageable stress as part of success itself (Sundararaman et al., 2025). Well-being should be measured on its own, not only as a predictor of grades.
Measure it with: Validated flourishing, stress, and mental health measures, with privacy protections. Counseling visits show contact, not improved health.
Where this dimension comes from
- USC: well-being
- CSU: belonging and well-being
What the research says
Depression predicted lower GPA and higher dropout, especially with anxiety (Eisenberg et al., 2009). These are longitudinal associations; they do not show how much treatment would raise completion.
Signs to watch for
- Sudden drop in attendance mid-term
- Repeated extensions or withdrawals
In practice
- Embed well-being into academic advising and course design, not only counseling.
- Watch workload and policies that create avoidable stress.
Technology touchpoint. Wellness apps carry the highest privacy stakes on this site.
Related on this site
5Material security Food, housing, money, and affordability: the conditions to participate at all.
Role: Condition. An enabling condition. Hardship is part of students’ experience, but security mainly makes participation possible.
Material security often works as an enabling condition rather than an educational outcome, but hardship is part of what students experience. Name it separately so it does not disappear inside “well-being.”
Measure it with: Unmet financial need, food and housing security, debt burden.
Where this dimension comes from
- CSU: well-being (partial)
- SREB: access and state supports (partial)
- Basic-needs research (Hope Center)
What the research says
Grant aid raised persistence and completion by about 2–3 percentage points across 43 causal studies (Nguyen et al., 2019). Food insecurity is consistently associated with lower GPA, but 46 of 47 studies in a 2026 review were cross-sectional, so causal claims are limited.
Signs to watch for
- Missing class for work shifts
- Unpaid balances blocking registration
In practice
- Make emergency aid fast and simple.
- Screen for basic needs during advising and connect students to benefits.
Technology touchpoint. Holds and automated balance notices can block the students least able to pay.
Related on this site
6Agency and purpose Self-efficacy, identity, goals, and the capacity to pursue them.
Role: Outcome and mechanism. Valued in its own right and also a pathway through which other outcomes are thought to improve.
Students describe personal growth, confidence, and meaningful goals as outcomes in their own right. Development theories such as self-authorship and identity development live here. Goals can change, and that is part of growth.
Measure it with: Self-efficacy, goal clarity, perceived progress toward self-defined goals.
Where this dimension comes from
- CSU: purpose and career
- ACE: life design
- SREB: student agency (partial)
- Sundararaman et al. (2025): personal growth; tenacity
What the research says
Academic self-efficacy correlated about .50 with GPA, and goals, self-efficacy, and study skills correlated .34–.37 with retention, beyond prior grades and income (Robbins et al., 2004). These are predictive findings; raising reported confidence does not guarantee proportional gains.
In practice
- Ask students to define their own goals at entry and revisit them.
- Give feedback that builds competence, not only grades.
Technology touchpoint. Planning tools should let students set and change their own goals.
Related on this site
7Career and opportunity Career readiness, meaningful work, earnings, and further study.
Role: Outcome. Something students achieve or experience, valued for its own sake.
Completion, employment, earnings, and meaningful work are separate outcomes. A degree gain does not automatically become an earnings gain.
Measure it with: Career readiness, employment quality, earnings, further education.
Where this dimension comes from
- USC: career readiness
- CSU: purpose and career
- ACE: career readiness
- York et al. (2015): career success
What the research says
Applications signaling an internship received 12.6% more interview invitations in a field experiment (Baert et al.). ASAP’s fourteen-year follow-up found lasting degree gains but no detectable earnings effect in New York State data.
Signs to watch for
- Low internship participation among Pell students
- Undeclared students late in the second year
In practice
- Introduce career exploration in the first year.
- Fund paid internships so lower-income students can take them.
Technology touchpoint. Career platforms should not steer students by demographic patterns.
Related on this site
8Civic and community contribution Using education to contribute to communities and public life.
Role: Outcome. Something students achieve or experience, valued for its own sake.
Many students, especially first-generation and students of color, describe giving back to their communities as a reason for college. Recognize contribution in many forms, not only formal volunteering.
Measure it with: Civic engagement, community contribution, intercultural learning.
Where this dimension comes from
- USC: social responsibility
- Sundararaman et al. (2025): giving back to communities
- Mayhew et al. (2016): values and moral development
What the research says
A meta-analysis of 27 studies (175,950 students) linked college diversity experiences to civic engagement, especially interpersonal interaction across race (Bowman, 2011). Civic outcomes are measured less consistently than grades or completion.
In practice
- Connect coursework to students’ communities.
- Count community and family contribution, not only campus service.
Related on this site
Sources
| USC | CSU | ACE | SREB | Kuh et al. 2006 | York et al. 2015 | Vugteveen et al. 2025 | Students (Sundararaman 2025) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Learning (outcome) | ◐ | ● | ● | — | ● | ● | ● | ◐ |
| Progress and completion (outcome) | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● | ● | ◐ |
| Belonging and validation (outcome and mechanism) | ◐ | ● | — | — | ◐ | — | ◐ | — |
| Health and well-being (outcome and condition) | ● | ● | — | — | — | — | — | ● |
| Material security (condition) | — | ◐ | — | ◐ | ◐ | — | — | ◐ |
| Agency and purpose (outcome and mechanism) | — | ● | ● | ◐ | — | — | ◐ | ● |
| Career and opportunity (outcome) | ● | ● | ● | — | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| Civic and community contribution (outcome) | ● | — | — | — | — | — | — | ● |
| Institutional capacity (condition) | — | ● | ● | ● | ● | — | ◐ | — |
- University of South Carolina
- Academic success, career readiness, experiential engagement, social responsibility, and well-being, treated as interconnected.
- Colorado State University
- Academic support and guidance, transitions, curricula and teaching, belonging and well-being, and purpose and career, organized around ecological validation. The ecological validation model comes from Kitchen et al. (2021).
- ACE Comprehensive Learner Success
- Curriculum and co-curriculum, career readiness, life design, completion, mobility, and institutional commitment, viewed through equity, data, and agility lenses.
- SREB pillars
- Access, persistence, retention, and attainment, linking student agency with institutional and state supports.
- Kuh et al. (2006)
- Academic achievement, engagement, satisfaction, knowledge and skills, persistence, attainment of objectives, and post-college performance, shaped by institutional conditions.
- York, Gibson, and Rankin (2015)
- Six components: achievement, satisfaction, skills and competencies, persistence, attainment of learning objectives, and career success.
- Vugteveen, Figueroa Esquivel, and Luijer (2025)
- A scoping review of 274 peer-reviewed studies (2011–2022) defining success as five dimensions: persistence and academic progress, academic performance, attainment of learning objectives, satisfaction, and career success, with psychosocial capital and institutional conditions as contributing factors.
- Students’ own definitions (Sundararaman et al., 2025)
- Academics and more, personal growth, well-being and balance, tenacity, giving back to communities, and career progress.
Around all eight dimensions
- Institutional capacity: leadership, staffing, coordination, data, and culture. A condition, not a student outcome.
- Equity: a standard for every dimension. Disaggregate each measure and ask whose goals count.
- Student-defined goals: ask students what success means to them and track progress toward it.
Keep four kinds of measures separate
- Outcomes: learning, completion, well-being, career.
- Mechanisms: belonging, self-efficacy, validation.
- Conditions: finances, teaching quality, access to information.
- Service activity: appointments, chatbot use, LMS logins. These show contact, not success.