Select a row for the details.
Integrated models (CUNY ASAP-type)Strong
Randomized trials show about 18 percentage points on three-year graduation, with replications in Ohio and Westchester.
Supplemental instruction and tutoringStrong
Grade effects of d ≈ 0.29–0.60 in a systematic review; stronger with higher dosage.
Basic needs (link to attrition)Strong
Dose-response links between unmet needs and attrition markers. Causal evidence for specific services is more limited.
Proactive advising and case managementModerate
Proactive advising with follow-up beats information-only outreach. Stay the Course found gains in persistence and completion for women.
High-impact practicesModerate
Consistent associations with engagement and retention; access is uneven. First-year seminars alone show small effects (δ ≈ 0.11).
Belonging and validationModerate
Small-to-moderate correlations with motivation and engagement; brief belonging interventions can narrow gaps.
Paid internshipsModerate
Linked to about 15 percent higher early earnings in matched analyses. Selection effects are likely.
Transitions and pathwaysEmerging
Promising descriptive and quasi-experimental results; few rigorous causal tests.
Standalone early alert and technologyMixed
Prediction is reasonable. Impact depends on high-quality human follow-up.
- Advising and case management
- Comprehensive, proactive advising with follow-up outperforms transactional or information-only approaches. Mentoring and coaching show modest effects on retention (d ≈ 0.15) and graduation (d ≈ 0.10). Evidence: moderate to strong.
- Supplemental instruction and tutoring
- Grade effects of d ≈ 0.29–0.60 in a systematic review, stronger with higher dosage and often for underrepresented students. Evidence: strong in better-controlled studies.
- High-impact practices
- First-year seminars, learning communities, undergraduate research, internships, and service learning are consistently associated with engagement, learning, and retention, sometimes with larger gains for Black and Latino students. First-year seminars alone show small retention effects (δ ≈ 0.11). Evidence: moderate.
- Transitions and entry
- Orientation, transfer supports, and clear pathways show promise in descriptive and quasi-experimental work. Critical for first-generation, transfer, and adult learners. Evidence: emerging.
- Basic needs and mental health
- National surveys often find about a third of students food insecure and nearly half housing insecure, with dose-response links to lower GPA and attrition. Counseling reduces distress and is associated with better academic functioning. Evidence: strong correlational; moderate for counseling.
- Career and experiential learning
- Paid internships are linked to higher early-career earnings, about 15 percent or roughly $3,000–$5,500 one year after graduation in matched analyses, and better job quality. Other experiential forms improve perceived preparedness more variably. Access is unequal. Evidence: moderate.
- Belonging and validation
- Small-to-moderate correlations with motivation, self-efficacy, and engagement; weaker with performance and retention. Brief social-belonging interventions can narrow gaps. Evidence: moderate correlational; emerging causal.
- Data systems and early alert
- Predictive models identify students reasonably well. Outcomes are mixed: alerts help only when paired with high-quality human action. Georgia State’s analytics-informed microgrants are a positive example. Evidence: moderate for prediction; mixed for impact.
- Leadership, policy, and culture
- Leadership commitment, staff development, policies such as registration holds, and shared responsibility enable everything else. Evidence: strong practical consensus; limited causal research.
- Cross-cutting supports
- Case management and coordinated care networks assign ownership and route students across silos. Assessment, external partnerships with K-12, employers, and community groups, and physical spaces for belonging and accessibility hold the system together. Evidence: strong for comprehensive case management; emerging for full coordinated care networks.