Integrated models show additive, and possibly multiplicative, effects. CUNY’s Accelerated Study in Associate Programs (ASAP) combined advising, tutoring, financial support, blocked schedules, and structured pathways. In randomized trials it nearly doubled three-year graduation rates, about 18 percentage points, with smaller but sustained gains at six years. Replications in Ohio and at Westchester Community College produced similar results, and cost per degree was often lower.
In Texas, the Stay the Course randomized trial found that case management plus emergency aid increased persistence and, for women, substantially raised degree completion.
- Early signalData and relationships
- Human follow-upA named person owns it
- Coordinated supportAcross offices
- LearningData for refinement
Implications for practice
- Assign every flagged student a named owner, and track whether contact actually happens.
- Evaluate processes, such as reach, dosage, and quality, alongside outcomes.
In the Campus Enterprise Model
Where this work sits in campus systems, capabilities, and data.