Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

3.6 · Student Success Frameworks

Defining success: outcomes frameworks

Researchers agree success is broader than grades and graduation. They differ on how to divide it up.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.

A working definition, offered as a synthesis rather than a quotation: student success is the equitable realization of meaningful educational and life goals through learning, development, supportive relationships, sustainable participation, and expanded opportunities to contribute and thrive during and after college.

Kuh et al. (2006)
Academic achievement, engagement, satisfaction, acquisition of knowledge and skills, persistence, attainment of educational objectives, and post-college performance.
York, Gibson, and Rankin (2015)
Six components of academic success: achievement, satisfaction, skills and competencies, persistence, attainment of learning objectives, and career success. Research often reduces success to GPA.
Weatherton and Schussler (2021)
Of 52 studies in one journal, 40% defined success explicitly, 88% measured it quantitatively, and only one asked students how they define it.
Sundararaman et al. (2025)
1,075 students at San Francisco State described six themes: academics and more, personal growth, well-being and balance, tenacity, giving back to communities, and career progress.
Vugteveen et al. (2025), scoping review of 274 studies
Five core dimensions: persistence and progress, academic performance, learning objectives, satisfaction, and career success, with factors grouped as background, psychosocial capital, educational experiences, and institutional conditions.
Lane and colleagues (2019)
An Australian capabilities framework organized around connectedness, mindsets, self-management, professional identity, and academic capabilities.
A ten-dimension proposal
Learning; progression and attainment; engagement; belonging; psychological well-being; financial well-being and basic needs; agency and identity; career and mobility; civic and ethical development; and equity as a cross-cutting standard.
This site’s eight dimensions
Learning; progress and completion; belonging and validation; health and well-being; material security; agency and purpose; career and opportunity; civic and community contribution, with institutional capacity and equity around all eight.

Keep three things separate

  • Outcomes: what students achieve and experience, such as belonging or completion.
  • Conditions: what shapes those outcomes, such as finances, climate, and curriculum.
  • Interventions: what the institution does, such as advising or aid. Belonging is a student experience; advising is a possible lever.