A working definition, offered as a synthesis rather than a quotation: student success is the equitable realization of meaningful educational and life goals through learning, development, supportive relationships, sustainable participation, and expanded opportunities to contribute and thrive during and after college.
- Kuh et al. (2006)
- Academic achievement, engagement, satisfaction, acquisition of knowledge and skills, persistence, attainment of educational objectives, and post-college performance.
- York, Gibson, and Rankin (2015)
- Six components of academic success: achievement, satisfaction, skills and competencies, persistence, attainment of learning objectives, and career success. Research often reduces success to GPA.
- Weatherton and Schussler (2021)
- Of 52 studies in one journal, 40% defined success explicitly, 88% measured it quantitatively, and only one asked students how they define it.
- Sundararaman et al. (2025)
- 1,075 students at San Francisco State described six themes: academics and more, personal growth, well-being and balance, tenacity, giving back to communities, and career progress.
- Vugteveen et al. (2025), scoping review of 274 studies
- Five core dimensions: persistence and progress, academic performance, learning objectives, satisfaction, and career success, with factors grouped as background, psychosocial capital, educational experiences, and institutional conditions.
- Lane and colleagues (2019)
- An Australian capabilities framework organized around connectedness, mindsets, self-management, professional identity, and academic capabilities.
- A ten-dimension proposal
- Learning; progression and attainment; engagement; belonging; psychological well-being; financial well-being and basic needs; agency and identity; career and mobility; civic and ethical development; and equity as a cross-cutting standard.
- This site’s eight dimensions
- Learning; progress and completion; belonging and validation; health and well-being; material security; agency and purpose; career and opportunity; civic and community contribution, with institutional capacity and equity around all eight.
Keep three things separate
- Outcomes: what students achieve and experience, such as belonging or completion.
- Conditions: what shapes those outcomes, such as finances, climate, and curriculum.
- Interventions: what the institution does, such as advising or aid. Belonging is a student experience; advising is a possible lever.