Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

3.10 · Student Success Frameworks

How evidence is classified on this site

Six evidence types, from strongest causal support to conceptual argument. Each claim should say which type it rests on.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.

Key terms

Randomized or strong quasi-experimental
Students or sites are randomly assigned, or a credible natural experiment exists. The best basis for saying an intervention caused a change.
Longitudinal observational
The same students are followed over time. Shows what predicts later outcomes; selection effects remain.
Cross-sectional
Measured at one point in time. Shows associations only.
Institutional case study
One campus or program describes its results. Useful for implementation detail; hard to generalize; gains often have several causes.
Vendor-reported
Results published by the company selling the tool. Treat as a claim to verify.
Conceptual synthesis
An argument or model built from prior research. Useful for design; not evidence that something works.

What to report for each claim

  • Research design (one of the six types above)
  • Population and context
  • Sample size, where available
  • Outcome measured
  • Main limitations
  • Primary citation