Select a row for the details.
Comprehensive support (CUNY ASAP and replications)Strong
Evidence type: Randomized. Randomized trials. CUNY: three-year graduation about 40% vs. 22%. ASAP Ohio: 35% vs. 19% at three years, 46% vs. 31% at eight, with year-eight earnings $3,337 higher. CUNY fourteen-year follow-up: 57.7% vs. 50.0% degree attainment, with no detectable earnings effect in New York State data. The finding is for the full package.
Active learning in STEMStrong
Evidence type: Meta-analysis of experiments. Freeman et al. (2014): exam performance up about 0.47 SD; lecture students about 1.5 times as likely to fail. Theobald et al. (2020): gaps for underrepresented students narrowed 33% on exams and 45% in pass rates.
Need-based grant aidStrong, small
Evidence type: Meta-analysis of causal studies. Grants raise persistence and attainment by about 2–3 percentage points; roughly 1.2 points per additional $1,000.
Individualized coachingStrong, specific
Evidence type: Randomized. Bettinger and Baker (2014): 3.4-point persistence gain after 24 months for the coaching model tested.
Brief belonging interventionsModerate
Evidence type: Randomized. Walton et al. (2023), 26,911 students at 22 institutions: gains for some groups where real opportunities to belong existed. A 2026 commentary notes null results for a prespecified hypothesis.
Faculty–student relationshipsAssociational
Evidence type: Cross-sectional and longitudinal (meta-analysis). Associated with academic outcomes (r ≈ .18) and persistence (r ≈ .33). These are associations, not effects of assigning mentors.
Guided PathwaysMixed
Evidence type: Longitudinal observational. About 100 colleges studied. Positive associations in Tennessee; no detected improvement after statewide initiatives in Ohio or Washington. Not causal.
Early-alert systemsMixed
Evidence type: Observational and randomized (mixed). An Australian study (16,091 students) found links to retention; a German randomized evaluation of warning emails found no average gain. Prediction is not intervention.
| Evidence type | Population and context | Sample | Outcome | Main limits | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ASAP Ohio | Randomized trial | Low-income students at three Ohio community colleges | About 1,500 students | Degree attainment at 3 and 8 years | Full-time students only; package cannot be separated |
| Active learning (Freeman et al., 2014) | Meta-analysis of experimental and quasi-experimental studies | Undergraduate STEM courses | 225 studies | Exam scores, failure rates | STEM only; possible publication bias |
| Active learning and gaps (Theobald et al., 2020) | Meta-analysis | Undergraduate STEM courses with disaggregated data | Studies reporting results by group | Exam scores, pass rates for underrepresented students | Effect depends on intensity of active learning |
| Grant aid (Nguyen et al., 2019) | Meta-analysis of causal studies | U.S. postsecondary students | 43 studies | Persistence, degree completion | Effects vary by program design |
| Coaching (Bettinger and Baker, 2014) | Randomized trial | Students at several institutions using one coaching provider | About 13,500 students | Persistence | One provider’s model |
| Belonging intervention (Walton et al., 2023) | Randomized trial | First-year students at 22 institutions | 26,911 students | First-year full-time completion | Gains only where real opportunities to belong existed |
| Guided Pathways | Longitudinal observational | Community colleges in several states | About 100 colleges | Early momentum, completion | Not causal; results differ by state |
| Early alert | Observational and one randomized evaluation | An Australian university; a German university | 16,091 students (Australia) | Retention | Observational links; randomized warning emails showed no average gain |