Learning analytics map most directly onto Astin’s quantity of involvement and NSSE-style engagement. They capture the quantitative side of involvement well and the qualitative side poorly.
Systematic reviews find promising but uneven evidence that learning analytics interventions improve study success; effects depend on how the insight is acted on (Ifenthaler & Yau, 2020).
Typical implementations
- Instructor dashboards showing inactive or falling-behind students.
- Student-facing progress indicators and nudges.
- Course-level reports linking activity to grades for course redesign.
Limitations and unintended consequences
- Clicks are a proxy for time, not for quality of effort or learning.
- Students in offline, lab, or studio-based courses look disengaged.
- Visible monitoring can feel like surveillance and change behavior without changing learning.
- Labels such as “at risk” can lower instructor expectations.
Implications for practice
- Pair activity data with brief student check-ins before acting.
- Show students their own data and explain what it means.
Theories behind this section
In the Campus Enterprise Model
Where this work sits in campus systems, capabilities, and data.