Dweck & Canning: Student and Faculty Mindsets
Beliefs about whether ability can grow (held by students and signaled by faculty) shape how students interpret setbacks; faculty and institutional mindsets may matter more than students’ own.
Key ideas
- 01 Fixed vs. growth: ability seen as innate or developable
- 02 Interpretation of setbacks: mindset shapes whether struggle means “I can’t” or “not yet”
- 03 Faculty mindset: instructors’ beliefs show up in grading, feedback, and gaps
- 04 Context: effects depend on peer norms and supportive settingsDiscussed in 2.4 Sense of belonging →
At a glance
- Beliefs about ability
- Student and instructor
- Interpretation of setbacks
- Faculty development
Helps explain
- Why some courses show larger equity gaps than others
- How feedback language affects persistence
- Why student-only mindset programs disappoint
In practice
Faculty development on feedback and grading, syllabus language, and course structures that reward improvement.
Critiques and limits
- Student-level intervention effects are small and contested
- Popularization has outrun the evidence
- Can shift blame to students’ attitudes
Evidence
Mixed. Meta-analyses estimate student intervention effects from d ≈ 0.05 (Macnamara & Burgoyne, 2023) to 0.14 (Burnette et al., 2023). Courses taught by STEM faculty who endorse fixed views showed racial gaps roughly twice as large (Canning et al., 2019).
Equity note. The strongest evidence points to faculty mindset as an equity lever: a reason to invest in instructors as well as students.
Related theories
References
Dweck, C. S. (2006). Mindset: The new psychology of success. Random House.