Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

9.2 · Practitioner Tools & Resources

One-page summaries of key theories

Short summaries of eight theories practitioners use most. Each links to the full page with key ideas, critiques, evidence, equity notes, and references.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.

At a glance

Tinto: Student Departure / Integration (1975; revised 1993)
Students persist when they achieve academic and social integration; departure is usually a process of insufficient integration rather than a single event. Key ideas: Academic integration; Social integration; Goals and commitments. In practice: First-year experience programs, learning communities, early alert systems, and orientation redesign.
Astin: Involvement / I-E-O Model (1984; I-E-O model 1991)
Student development is proportional to the quality and quantity of involvement: the physical and psychological energy students devote to the academic experience. Key ideas: Inputs; Environment; Outcomes. In practice: High-impact practices, student employment, peer mentoring, and co-curricular involvement tracking.
Strayhorn: Sense of Belonging (2012; 2nd ed. 2019)
Belonging is a fundamental human need and a strong predictor of success, particularly for students from marginalized or underrepresented groups. Key ideas: Mattering; Connectedness; Fit. In practice: Mentoring, affinity spaces, culturally engaging campus environments, and “village” or community-based approaches.
Kuh: Student Engagement / High-Impact Practices (NSSE 2000; HIPs 2008)
Success depends on what students do and what institutions do to induce them into educationally purposeful activities, especially high-impact practices. Key ideas: Engagement; NSSE; High-impact practices. In practice: HIP audits, scaling undergraduate research and internships, and using NSSE data to guide improvement.
Rendón: Validation Theory (1994)
Students succeed when in- and out-of-class agents actively affirm them as capable learners and valued members of the community. Key ideas: Validation; Academic validation; Interpersonal validation. In practice: Faculty outreach in the first weeks, culturally relevant pedagogy, community college bridge programs, and proactive advising.
Schlossberg: Transition Theory (1981; later revisions with Goodman and Anderson)
How well people cope with a transition depends on four factors (situation, self, support, and strategies) which can be assessed and strengthened. Key ideas: Types of transitions; Moving in, through, and out; The 4 S’s. In practice: Orientation and transfer services, veteran and adult learner programs, and career transitions at graduation.
Yosso: Community Cultural Wealth (2005)
Students of color bring forms of capital that institutions often fail to recognize, and those assets support their success. Key ideas: Aspirational capital; Linguistic capital; Familial capital. In practice: Asset-based advising, culturally sustaining curricula, and family engagement programs.
Schreiner: Thriving (2010; 2012)
Success means more than staying enrolled: thriving students are engaged academically, connected to others, and psychologically well. Key ideas: Academic thriving; Interpersonal thriving; Intrapersonal thriving. In practice: Assessment beyond retention, strengths-based advising, and well-being programs integrated with academics.

Theories behind this section