Student Success by DesignA practitioner’s guide to theory, data, and AI in student success

9.8 · Practitioner Tools & Resources

Framework explorer: start from a challenge

Pick an institutional challenge to see which frameworks help, which technology applies, what to measure, and where to read more.

Short shows the summary, takeaway, and questions.
Interactive explorer · Eight common institutional challenges

Select an element for details.

1First-year attrition Students leave between the first and second term.

Start by asking which students leave and why. Departure usually has several causes, and the mix differs for residential, commuting, and working students.

Measure it with: Term 1 to term 2 persistence by group; time from flag to contact

Frameworks that help

  • Tinto (2017): motivation, self-efficacy, belonging, perceived value of the curriculum
  • Bean and Metzner: work, finances, and family
  • Schlossberg: transitions and mattering

Technology touchpoint. Early alert with guaranteed human follow-up

2Equity gaps in gateway courses Pass rates differ sharply by group in early required courses.

Gateway courses are where many students first decide whether they belong in a field. Teaching practice is one of the strongest levers available.

Measure it with: DFW rates by group; exam performance; belonging in the course

Frameworks that help

  • Active learning research (Freeman; Theobald)
  • Museus: culturally engaging environments
  • Rendón: validation in the classroom

Technology touchpoint. Course-level learning analytics shared with instructors

3Low belonging among commuters and working students Students who are not on campus much report feeling disconnected.

Most belonging programs assume students have free time on campus. Build connection into class time and schedules students already have.

Measure it with: Belonging scale by attendance pattern; participation in embedded activities

Frameworks that help

Technology touchpoint. Scheduling tools and CRM outreach timed to students’ hours

4Alerts that no one acts on Flags are raised but students are not contacted.

This is an operating-architecture problem. The tool works; the workflow behind it does not.

Measure it with: Share of flags with human contact within 48 hours; faculty alert submission over time

Frameworks that help

  • Kitchen et al.: ecological validation
  • Implementation research on student success technology

Technology touchpoint. CRM case ownership with response-time tracking

5Basic needs and stop-outs Students leave mid-term because of money, food, or housing.

Material security is a condition for everything else. Fast, simple help keeps many students enrolled.

Measure it with: Unmet need; time to award emergency aid; mid-term withdrawals

Frameworks that help

  • Bean and Metzner: environmental factors
  • Basic-needs research (Hope Center)
  • Material security dimension

Technology touchpoint. Emergency aid workflow and benefits screening in advising

6Evaluating an AI advisor or chatbot A vendor offers an AI assistant for advising questions.

Ask whether it frees advisors for relationships or replaces them, and whether students can reach a person easily.

Measure it with: Accuracy of answers; handoffs to people; student-reported belonging and trust

Frameworks that help

  • Rendón: validation
  • Self-determination theory: autonomy and competence
  • Student voice frameworks

Technology touchpoint. AI advising assistant with clear handoff to people

7Data sharing across offices Offices cannot see each other’s referrals or notes.

Coordination needs shared data, and shared data needs clear rules students would recognize as fair.

Measure it with: Referral completion; time between referral and contact; student awareness of data use

Frameworks that help

  • Data governance roles and decision rights
  • Kitchen et al.: coordinated validation

Technology touchpoint. Shared case record with role-based access

8Choosing a campus-wide framework Leaders want one model to organize student success work.

No single framework covers everything. Give each one a job: outcomes, conditions, mechanisms, practices, and evaluation.

Measure it with: A written theory of change for each major initiative

Frameworks that help

  • Six kinds of frameworks
  • Framework profiles
  • Layered approach to frameworks

Technology touchpoint. Planning and dashboard tools aligned to the chosen outcomes